shivamagroind

Iron Fertilizer

Ferrous Bisglycinate vs Ferrous Sulphate for Food Fortification

A proposed trial comparing Ferrous Bisglycinate and Ferrous Sulphate in iron-fortified whole wheat atta, covering iron matching, sensory checks, storage and batch cost.

Shivam Agro Industries Published 6 min read Share WhatsAppLinkedIn

A fortification team developing an iron fortified whole wheat atta has two candidate iron sources: Ferrous Bisglycinate and Ferrous Sulphate. The choice depends on how each behaves in this flour and in the chapatis made from it, and on what each costs at the addition rate that delivers the same iron. This article sets out a proposed trial for that atta, beginning with the details a buyer should confirm with Shivam Agro Industries or any other supplier before weighing a sample.

Ferrous Bisglycinate and Ferrous Sulphate Specifications for Food Fortification

Shivam Agro Industries lists Ferrous Bisglycinate, also referred to as Iron Glycine Chelate, in its product range. Before calculating the trial dose, request the quoted grade, the lot’s elemental iron content and the basis on which the assay is reported.

The company also manufactures Dried Ferrous Sulphate as a separate product. For the Ferrous Sulphate sample in this proposed trial, confirm the same details along with documentation of the grade’s suitability for the intended food application.

Setting Up a Ferrous Bisglycinate Fortification Trial in Atta

Atta lets the trial observe the iron source twice: in the dry flour that is packed and stored, and in the cooked chapati that consumers eat.

Prepare three samples from one base recipe: an unfortified control, a Ferrous Bisglycinate sample and a Ferrous Sulphate sample. Hold constant the batch size, flour lot, carrier used to predisperse the iron source, blending sequence and time, dough water ratio, resting time, griddle temperature and cooking time. Make each batch large enough for the baseline assessment and every planned storage interval.

The control goes through every step, including blending with the same quantity of carrier. It shows how the atta and chapati look, taste and change without added iron, giving the reference against which differences in the fortified samples are observed.

Keep each trial ingredient sample sealed in its supplied packaging until weighing, and log its lot number against the batch. If one iron source needs a different step, such as longer blending, record it as a trial difference.

Need a quote or a test report?Tell us the product and quantity. We reply the same day.

Matching Elemental Iron Between Ferrous Sulphate and Ferrous Bisglycinate

Both fortified batches receive the same target amount of added elemental iron, so their ingredient masses differ:

Ingredient mass per batch = target added elemental iron per batch ÷ elemental iron mass fraction

Convert the percentage to a decimal first by dividing it by 100, and keep units consistent.

  • T = target added elemental iron per batch (g), identical for both samples
  • F₁ = elemental iron mass fraction of the Ferrous Bisglycinate lot, as received
  • F₂ = elemental iron mass fraction of the Ferrous Sulphate lot, as received
  • Q₁ = T ÷ F₁ and Q₂ = T ÷ F₂

If a lot certificate reports iron on a dry basis, obtain the as received value from the supplier of that lot, because the material is weighed as received.

T covers only iron from the added ingredient. Iron already in the atta is equal across all three samples and is reflected in the control. T is a trial setting, not a recommended fortification level.

Colour and Flavour Testing of Iron Glycine Chelate and Ferrous Sulphate Samples

Assess the samples soon after preparation, as flour and as chapati, using random three digit codes and a randomised serving order.

For colour, present the flours in identical containers and the chapatis on one neutral background under a single fixed light source. Note any shift in shade or visible specks compared with the control. Teams with a colorimeter can add instrumental readings.

For flavour, where tasting is permitted under the team’s procedures, serve chapatis at the same temperature and portion size, with water between samples. Record:

  • Departures from the expected atta flavour
  • Metallic or other off notes
  • Aftertaste, and whether it appears immediately or later

Score each fortified sample against the control rather than on general liking. These records become the storage baseline.

Storage Checks for Ferrous Bisglycinate and Ferrous Sulphate Atta Samples

Pack the three flours in the same material, fill weight and seal, and store them together under conditions representing the intended distribution. At review intervals suited to the expected life of this atta, open fresh packs, cook chapatis and repeat the baseline assessment.

Compare each sample with its own baseline and with the control at the same storage interval.

  • A change seen in all three samples should not be attributed to either added iron source alone.
  • A change only in a fortified sample, or clearly larger there, is a difference observed with that iron source in this trial.

Also note physical changes such as lumping. Keep a sealed retained portion of each trial ingredient lot, so a change traced to one fortified sample can be checked against the same ingredient material.

Sensory checks cannot establish iron content or bioavailability, and the trial does not establish shelf life.

Ferrous Bisglycinate vs Ferrous Sulphate Cost per Batch

Apply Q₁ and Q₂, calculated in grams, to the supplier quotes:

Ingredient cost per batch = ingredient quantity per batch × quoted price per matching weight unit

When prices are quoted per kilogram, divide the gram quantity by 1,000 first.

Confirm that quotes from Shivam Agro Industries and any other supplier use the same currency, weight unit and terms for taxes, freight and packaging. Price per kilogram alone does not show batch cost: the source with the lower iron fraction needs more mass to deliver T, so a lower price per kilogram can still give a higher cost per batch.

Iron source Required quantity per batch (g) Quoted unit price (per kg) Calculated batch cost
Ferrous Bisglycinate Q₁ Input: P₁ (Q₁ ÷ 1,000) × P₁
Ferrous Sulphate Q₂ Input: P₂ (Q₂ ÷ 1,000) × P₂

The result covers direct ingredient cost only.

About Shivam Agro Industries, an Iron Glycine Chelate Supplier

Shivam Agro Industries is a manufacturer, exporter and supplier based at Ranasan G.I.D.C., Vijapur, Mehsana, Gujarat. Its iron ingredients include Ferrous Bisglycinate (Iron Glycine Chelate) and Dried Ferrous Sulphate, within a wider product portfolio covering EDTA products, glycine and bisglycinates of zinc, magnesium, manganese, copper and calcium.

Selecting the Iron Source After the Ferrous Bisglycinate Trial

Set acceptance criteria for colour, flavour and storage behaviour before comparing results, then use cost per batch to choose among the samples that meet them. Because each treatment comes from a single preparation, repeat promising treatments in independent batches before selecting one. When contacting Shivam Agro Industries, share the intended food application and request the grade documentation the trial requires.

Ferrous BisglycinateSee specifications and request a sample
View product

Request a quote

Leave your details and our team will call you back.

Written by Shivam Agro Industries

Manufacturer and supplier of industrial chemicals.

Need help choosing a grade or supplier?Chat with us on WhatsApp: +91 98254 65361